Abstract
Background
Recent studies looking to advance knowledge of fire-effects on trees have used both heated water baths and experimental laboratory fires to apply heat to plant tissues.
Aims
We assessed whether heated water baths and experimental laboratory fires caused xylem cell wall deformation and increased vulnerability to embolism.
Methods
Using Pinus ponderosa and Pinus monticola saplings, we measured impacts using both heated water bath treatments and experimental laboratory fires, with parameters elucidated by prior studies that observed effects associated with lethal outcomes.
Key results
We show that increased vulnerability to embolism only occurred in one of the species tested when using the heated water baths and did not occur in either species when using the laboratory fire treatments. Neither treatment caused xylem cell deformations.
Conclusions
Heated water baths may generate misleading results in some species and therefore should be used with caution when researching effects due to wildland fires.
Implications
Future studies should assess the potential of other common fire dynamics proxy methods.