Logo image
Brassica biofumigation cover crops in US agroecosystems: A systematic review of research from 2014 to 2024
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Brassica biofumigation cover crops in US agroecosystems: A systematic review of research from 2014 to 2024

Karthik Karuppanan, Vigneshwaran Raja, Jemila Chellappa, Joel Felix and Udayakumar Sekaran
Agronomy journal, Vol.118(3), pp.1-18
05/2026

Abstract

Biofumigation with brassica cover crops (BCCs) is gaining momentum in the United States as an ecologically sound alternative to chemical pest suppression in agricultural systems. This review critically evaluates the impacts of Brassica species on soil health, weed suppression, disease mitigation, and control of plant‐parasitic nematodes (PPNs) across US agroecosystems over the last decade (2014–2024). Synthesizing data from over 50 peer‐reviewed studies, we found that brassicas, particularly mustard ( Brassica juncea ), radish ( Raphanus sativus ), and canola ( Brassica napus ), exert a significant biofumigation effect due to the release of allelochemicals, notably isothiocyanates, during residue decomposition. BCCs exhibit mixed effects on soil physical and chemical health, with certain species, such as turnip ( Brassica rapa ) and mustard, alleviating soil compaction and improving organic carbon under specific conditions. In contrast, others, such as canola, may reduce soil water content or microbial diversity due to high biomass demand or the release of allelochemicals. While 87.5% of the studies observed disease suppression and 60% reported nematode control, weed suppression showed variable outcomes, depending on Brassica species and management practices. Mustard was notably effective in pathogen control, while daikon radish consistently suppressed soybean cyst and reniform nematodes. However, some Brassica species acted as hosts to certain nematodes under specific conditions, highlighting the complexity of plant‐nematode interactions. Additionally, limited data exist on long‐term soil structural and chemical changes, particularly under arid or saline conditions prevalent in the western United States. This review identifies critical research gaps, including the need for integrated, multi‐functional assessments; long‐term trials; and innovative tools such as spatial‐spectral sensing, modeling approaches, and microbial functional profiling. Future research should prioritize exploring brassica performance under abiotic stress, assessing region‐specific impacts, and developing decision‐support tools to optimize biofumigation practices. Biofumigation using brassica cover crops is becoming more popular in the United States as a natural option to reduce pests in agriculture. This review examines how brassica crops, such as mustard, radish, and canola, affect soil health, weeds, diseases, and plant‐parasitic nematodes, based on studies published from 2014 to 2024. The results from more than 50 studies show that these crops release natural chemicals during decomposition that can suppress pests. Some species, such as mustard and turnip, can also reduce soil compaction and increase soil carbon under certain conditions. Most studies showed positive effects on disease reduction and nematode control, but weed suppression varied by species and management. The review highlights the need for long‐term studies, improved tools such as sensors and modeling, and further research on how brassicas perform under different climates and stress conditions.
url
https://doi.org/10.1002/agj2.70388View
Published (Version of record) Open

Metrics

1 Record Views

Details

Logo image